Ethereum was close to flipping Bitcoin in 2017 — then never again

This is a segment from the Supply Shock newsletter. To read full editions, subscribe.

Just one coin has ever come close to flipping bitcoin, around this time, eight years ago.

In June 2017, bitcoin was in the final stages of warming up for a historic push to nearly $20,000 by Christmas.

Altcoin prices were wacky. Bitcoin would be flat one week, while coins like BitShares would jump massively, by 250%. Others, like Stratis and DigiByte, were down up to 50% in the same period.

Ethereum, meanwhile, was poised for an explosion in token projects. One study calculated that $7 billion flowed into ICOs throughout 2017, practically all of it going to Ethereum-based projects. That was supposedly 4x more than the equity investments into crypto companies across the same period.

The price of ETH rose as investors piled into coin offerings through Ethereum’s native token. And on June 12, the market cap of ETH came within 17% of surpassing bitcoin’s: $36.8 billion to $44.3 billion.

Had bitcoin stayed flat, ETH would’ve only needed to jump from $400 to $470 to slide into the No. 1 spot.

This banger from the New York Time was published days earlier.

But it would never be: BTC and ETH both fell by 60% over the next month, preceding a 10x pump through the end of the bull market for BTC — but only a 9x for ETH. Ether never made the ground back.

By late June 2017, it was becoming clear the Flippening was no longer realistic.